The question you raise is profound and one that many believers wrestle with, for the enemy seeks to confuse and discourage us, while God works all things for our good—even the trials that feel like loss. The key to discerning whether your struggles are from the Lord’s refining hand, His loving discipline, or the enemy’s attacks lies in examining the *fruit* of the season, the *state of your heart*, and the *Word of God* itself.
First, let us consider the refining work of the Lord. Scripture tells us that God tests and purifies His children as a refiner does with silver, removing impurities so that His reflection may be seen more clearly in us. *"He will sit as a refiner and purifier of silver... he will purify the sons of Levi, and refine them as gold and silver; and they shall offer to Yahweh offerings in righteousness"* (Malachi 3:3, WEB). If what you are experiencing is drawing you *closer* to God—if it is producing humility, dependence on Him, a deeper hunger for His Word, and a greater love for holiness—then it is likely the Lord’s refining work. His discipline, though painful, is always rooted in love and yields *"the peaceful fruit of righteousness"* (Hebrews 12:11, WEB). Ask yourself: *Is this season making me more like Christ?* If the answer is yes, then trust that God is at work, even if the process is difficult.
Now, if the hardship you face is a consequence of willful sin—arrogance, rebellion, or unrepentant disobedience—then it may indeed be the Lord’s discipline. *"Don’t be deceived. God is not mocked, for whatever a man sows, that he will also reap"* (Galatians 6:7, WEB). The Lord disciplines those He loves (Hebrews 12:6), and His correction is meant to turn us back to Him. If the Holy Spirit has been convicting you of a specific sin, and the trials you face align with the natural consequences of that sin, then repentance is the path forward. *"If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us the sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness"* (1 John 1:9, WEB). The Lord’s discipline is never without hope; it is always an invitation to return to Him.
But we must also be vigilant against the schemes of the enemy. Satan comes *"only to steal, kill, and destroy"* (John 10:10, WEB), and his attacks are marked by *confusion, despair, isolation, and a pulling away from God*. If what you are experiencing is filling you with bitterness, fear, or a desire to abandon your faith, then it is not from the Lord. The enemy will twist truths, magnify lies, and seek to make you believe that God has abandoned you. Yet Jesus assures us: *"I came that they may have life, and may have it abundantly"* (John 10:10, WEB). If the struggle is pushing you toward hopelessness rather than holiness, resist the devil firmly in the name of Jesus, and he *will* flee (James 4:7).
So how do you discern? **Examine the fruit.** Is this season producing godliness in you, or is it breeding resentment and distance from God? **Search your heart.** Is the Holy Spirit convicting you of unconfessed sin? **Test the spirits.** Does what you’re hearing align with Scripture, or is it a lie from the pit of hell? And above all, **draw near to God**. *"You will seek me, and find me, when you search for me with all your heart"* (Jeremiah 29:13, WEB). In His presence, the fog of confusion lifts, and His voice becomes clear.
Let us pray for you now:
Heavenly Father, we lift up Your child to You, asking for wisdom and discernment in this season of trial. Lord, if this is Your refining fire, grant them the grace to endure it with joy, knowing that You are molding them into the image of Christ. If it is Your loving discipline, soften their heart to repentance and restoration, that they may walk in the fullness of Your forgiveness. And if it is the enemy’s attack, we rebuke every lie and scheme in the mighty name of Jesus. Fill them with Your peace, Your truth, and Your unshakable assurance that You are working all things for their good.
Remind them, Lord, that even when they cannot see Your hand, they can trust Your heart. Strengthen their faith to believe that You are good, that Your plans for them are good, and that no weapon formed against them shall prosper. Guard their mind from the enemy’s accusations and fill them with the certainty of Your love. May they emerge from this season with a deeper dependence on You, a greater testimony of Your faithfulness, and a heart fully surrendered to Your will.
We ask this in the powerful and matchless name of Jesus Christ, our Lord and Savior. Amen.
Finally, we encourage you to spend time in the Psalms, where David often wrestled with similar questions. Psalm 139 is a particularly powerful prayer in seasons of uncertainty, reminding us that God knows us intimately and is present even in our darkest moments. Cling to His promises, stand firm on His Word, and trust that He who began a good work in you will complete it (Philippians 1:6). You are not alone in this—He is with you, and He is for you.