I hear the ache in your words, and I want to speak gently yet honestly to your heart. When you say it is broken, I believe you. That pain is real, and God draws near to the brokenhearted. But I also want to lift your eyes to something deeper, because the passages you’ve stirred in my own spirit keep circling back to this: our relationships with others are never truly safe or whole until our relationship with God is first.
You long for a committed, beautiful love with this man. That’s not a wrong desire in itself. But the Scriptures ask a searching question: Can two walk together unless they are agreed? If the deepest part of you belongs to Jesus Christ, and the deepest part of him does not, then you are pulling in opposite directions while trying to build one life. That isn’t a narrow path of temporary frustration, it’s a fundamental mismatch that will press your heart into an even narrower place over time. Love that is merely human, no matter how intense, cannot substitute for a shared spiritual foundation.
You mentioned past issues. I don’t know all that history holds, but I do know that genuine love, the kind God gives, is not rooted in desperation or in winning someone’s affection. The love Jesus offers us is strong as death, and it cannot be bought or coaxed out of another person. If you are hoping your tenderness and patience will eventually draw him toward faith, that hope can become a broken cistern that holds no water. Many have walked that road only to find their own hearts parched and divided.
What I would pray for you first is not a change in him, but a release in your own spirit. My heart is enlarged toward you in this, meaning I long for you to be freed from that pressure. Let Jesus Himself become your shepherd lover, the one whose kindness truly ravishes the heart. When you know, deep in your bones, that you are loved with an everlasting love, that changes what you seek in a human partner. You stop clinging to a love that may never return what you offer, and you begin to want only what your Lord wants for you. If this man cannot share your first love, your devotion will always be split, and a divided heart breaks God’s heart too. He wants your full devotion, not a half-hearted arrangement where you pour yourself out for someone who can’t join you in worshiping the living God.
So I urge you: make your primary prayer not for the relationship you envision, but for a whole heart. Ask the Lord to search you and cut away whatever lusts after something He has not ordained. The law of love begins with loving God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength. When He is supreme, your ability to love another person rightly will flow from that, and you will have clarity about whether this man can stand beside you in that love. True spiritual romance is found in being equally yoked, bound together by the same Spirit, bringing forth the fruit of joy and peace and goodness.
Your heartache does not go unseen. Bring that sorrow to Jesus, let Him hold it, and let His love call you back to your first love. If you are willing to trust Him, even if it means releasing this man, He will enlarge your heart beyond this narrow pain. He promises pastors after His own heart who will feed you with knowledge and understanding. Let His Word unravel this for you personally, in the quiet of your devotions, until His love is perfected in your life and you know whose you truly are.