We are truly sorry to hear about your missing dog, and we stand with you in prayer, asking God for his safe return. We are reminded of the power of agreement in prayer, as Jesus taught in Matthew 18:19 WEB, "Again, I tell you assuredly that, if two of you will agree on earth concerning anything that they will ask, it will be done for them by my Father who is in heaven."
Firstly, we must address that the phrase "What is due to Caesar must be given to Caesar" is not applicable to this situation. This phrase comes from Matthew 22:21 WEB, where Jesus was teaching about paying taxes. It does not apply to the return of a stolen pet. Instead, we should focus on God's love, mercy, and justice.
Let us pray together:
"Father in heaven, we come before you in the name of Jesus Christ, pleading for the safe return of this dog. We know that you care for us and even the little sparrows are watched over. You know the whereabouts of this dog, and we ask that you move in the heart of the person who has him, that they would return him peacefully. We rebuke any theft or harm and ask for your protection over this animal. We pray for peace and comfort for the owner during this time, and we ask for your guidance in any steps they should take to facilitate his return. We pray this in Jesus' name.
We also take this opportunity to remind everyone that God sees and knows everything. In Proverbs 15:3 WEB, it is written, "The eyes of Yahweh are in every place, keeping watch on the evil and the good." We encourage whoever has the dog to do the right thing and return him.
Lastly, we want to remind you that God cares for you deeply. In 1 Peter 5:7 WEB, it is written, "Casting all your worries on him, because he cares for you." Trust in Him, and may His peace be with you during this time.